2014/03/19 13:48
한 인권운동가의 페북에서 수원시장 염태영 씨가 종종 언급되기에 옛 글을 꺼내 읽었다. 염태영은 이 글에 나오는 진보 교회의 청년부 회장이었다. 당시 수원 지역의 학생운동은 오래 전부터 있던 서울대 농대에 몇해 전 서울에서 옮겨온 한신대가 보태어진 형국이었는데, 염태영 은 나보다 두어 살 많은 서울대 농대 학생이었다. 그는 학생운동을 했고 시민운동(환경운동)을 했으며 노무현 정권에서 청와대에서 일했고 수원시장이 되었다. 말하자면 그는 오늘 한국 자유주의 정치세력의 매우 전형적인 행로를 걸어왔다. 두달 만에 교회에 나타난 나에게 ‘네 무책임함을 도저히 이해할 수 없다’고 질책하던 그의 얼굴이 떠오른다. 그의 질책은 정당했지만 우정이 느껴지진 않았다. 그날 교회를 나오는 나를 쫓아와 소주를 사준 C형이 생각난다. C형은 식품회사에서 노조를 만들다 해고된 후 복사가게를 하며 지역 노동운동에 열심이었다. 염태영의 '모범적 처신'에 늘 씁쓸해 하던 C형은 이젠 어디서 뭘 하는지 모른다. 한 사람은 운동으로 제도에 진출했고 한 사람은 운동으로 제도에 스러져갔다. 돌이켜보면 두 사람의 다른 현재는 그 즈음 이미 정해져 있었다. 내가 사적으로 알지 못한 수많은 운동권들의 다른 현재도 그 즈음에 다 정해져 있었을 것이다. 오늘 역시 많은 것들이 정해지고 있다.
2014/03/19 13:48 2014/03/19 13:48

트랙백 주소 :: http://gyuhang.net/trackback/2935

  1. Subject: Forex Smart Pips Robot by Den Murakami Review

    Tracked from Forex Smart Pips Robot by Den Murakami Review 2014/05/10 07:09  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  2. Subject: vegan diet weight loss

    Tracked from vegan diet weight loss 2014/06/06 08:04  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  3. Subject: does spanish fly work?

    Tracked from does spanish fly work? 2014/06/10 20:26  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  4. Subject: maillot de bain

    Tracked from maillot de bain 2014/06/16 17:45  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  5. Subject: Digest It Review

    Tracked from Digest It Review 2014/06/18 05:26  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  6. Subject: easy work at home jobs

    Tracked from easy work at home jobs 2014/06/18 10:02  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  7. Subject: Pure Garcinia Cambogia review

    Tracked from Pure Garcinia Cambogia review 2014/06/18 18:08  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  8. Subject: katieandkirk.com

    Tracked from katieandkirk.com 2014/06/21 09:42  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  9. Subject: sharing

    Tracked from sharing 2014/06/22 06:25  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  10. Subject: morgellonsdisease.net

    Tracked from morgellonsdisease.net 2014/06/22 12:39  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  11. Subject: snel lijnen

    Tracked from snel lijnen 2014/06/22 18:16  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  12. Subject: woodworking machine

    Tracked from woodworking machine 2014/06/23 03:48  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  13. Subject: voyance

    Tracked from voyance 2014/06/23 05:59  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  14. Subject: Highly recommended Web-site

    Tracked from Highly recommended Web-site 2014/06/23 12:24  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  15. Subject: aptamil pre uk

    Tracked from aptamil pre uk 2014/06/23 23:01  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  16. Subject: pawn shops online las vegas

    Tracked from pawn shops online las vegas 2014/06/24 19:36  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  17. Subject: tablette samsung pas cher

    Tracked from tablette samsung pas cher 2014/06/25 10:45  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  18. Subject: soniya รักษาสิว

    Tracked from soniya รักษาสิว 2014/06/25 15:19  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  19. Subject: Towing Software

    Tracked from Towing Software 2014/06/26 09:44  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  20. Subject: google seo tips 2014

    Tracked from google seo tips 2014 2014/06/27 02:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  21. Subject: serveur privé wow

    Tracked from serveur privé wow 2014/06/27 08:50  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  22. Subject: irs tax attorney

    Tracked from irs tax attorney 2014/06/27 18:07  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  23. Subject: sejour balneaire

    Tracked from sejour balneaire 2014/06/27 22:09  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  24. Subject: Dien dan sidonyaotel

    Tracked from Dien dan sidonyaotel 2014/06/27 22:13  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  25. Subject: dental implants

    Tracked from dental implants 2014/06/29 11:18  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  26. Subject: gmat sample questions

    Tracked from gmat sample questions 2014/06/30 03:37  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  27. Subject: Venapro Reviews

    Tracked from Venapro Reviews 2014/06/30 04:41  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  28. Subject: gre sample test

    Tracked from gre sample test 2014/06/30 12:17  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  29. Subject: Reputation Definition

    Tracked from Reputation Definition 2014/07/01 02:38  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  30. Subject: search engine submission

    Tracked from search engine submission 2014/07/02 21:05  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  31. Subject: Create Flash Banner

    Tracked from Create Flash Banner 2014/07/03 01:06  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  32. Subject: Project.sparcs.org

    Tracked from Project.sparcs.org 2014/07/04 07:38  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  33. Subject: opiate addiction

    Tracked from opiate addiction 2014/07/05 02:22  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  34. Subject: Blackline Elite

    Tracked from Blackline Elite 2014/07/06 13:48  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  35. Subject: handbag Shops

    Tracked from handbag Shops 2014/07/07 20:51  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  36. Subject: gre practice

    Tracked from gre practice 2014/07/08 22:02  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  37. Subject: eye lash

    Tracked from eye lash 2014/07/09 10:22  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  38. Subject: clash of clans cheats

    Tracked from clash of clans cheats 2014/07/09 11:01  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  39. Subject: Prodermagenix Trial

    Tracked from Prodermagenix Trial 2014/07/10 10:23  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  40. Subject: vacances caraibes

    Tracked from vacances caraibes 2014/07/10 15:55  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  41. Subject: www.nafso-online.org

    Tracked from www.nafso-online.org 2014/07/13 09:55  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  42. Subject: vitamin b6

    Tracked from vitamin b6 2014/07/14 16:14  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  43. Subject: px com

    Tracked from px com 2014/07/15 07:44  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  44. Subject: https://iqmax.zendesk.com/entries/49110920-Does-Retinol-Acne-Treatment-Work-6-Retinol-Acne-Cure-Facts

    Tracked from https://iqmax.zendesk.com/entries/49110920-Does-Retinol-Acne-Treatment-Work-6-Retinol-Acne-Cure-Facts 2014/07/15 13:11  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  45. Subject: persimmon homes

    Tracked from persimmon homes 2014/07/17 03:34  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  46. Subject: www.ozads.com.au

    Tracked from www.ozads.com.au 2014/07/18 02:03  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  47. Subject: where to buy garcinia cambogia in stores

    Tracked from where to buy garcinia cambogia in stores 2014/07/18 03:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  48. Subject: home renovations

    Tracked from home renovations 2014/07/18 08:27  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  49. Subject: building a house

    Tracked from building a house 2014/07/18 11:40  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  50. Subject: payday loan

    Tracked from payday loan 2014/07/18 16:47  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  51. Subject: bag

    Tracked from bag 2014/07/18 19:57  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  52. Subject: instant cash advance online

    Tracked from instant cash advance online 2014/07/20 09:13  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  53. Subject: prefabricated homes

    Tracked from prefabricated homes 2014/07/20 22:45  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  54. Subject: diet plan for weight loss

    Tracked from diet plan for weight loss 2014/07/22 04:30  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  55. Subject: Cleanse Wonder

    Tracked from Cleanse Wonder 2014/07/22 13:41  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  56. Subject: earn money at home

    Tracked from earn money at home 2014/07/23 23:10  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  57. Subject: the original source

    Tracked from the original source 2014/07/24 03:22  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  58. Subject: Www.Fort-Awesome.Net

    Tracked from Www.Fort-Awesome.Net 2014/07/26 17:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  59. Subject: https://Trac.acceleration.net/testfortimingandestimation/ticket/69343

    Tracked from https://Trac.acceleration.net/testfortimingandestimation/ticket/69343 2014/07/27 02:39  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  60. Subject: my top tier business

    Tracked from my top tier business 2014/07/27 04:15  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  61. Subject: gnc testosterone

    Tracked from gnc testosterone 2014/07/27 16:57  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  62. Subject: weight loss resources

    Tracked from weight loss resources 2014/07/27 20:39  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  63. Subject: fort-awesome.net

    Tracked from fort-awesome.net 2014/07/28 00:47  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  64. Subject: muscle building routine

    Tracked from muscle building routine 2014/07/29 18:49  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  65. Subject: Xbox Live Gold Code Generator Free

    Tracked from Xbox Live Gold Code Generator Free 2014/07/30 12:19  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  66. Subject: Epistemological knowledge

    Tracked from Epistemological knowledge 2014/07/31 08:31  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  67. Subject: weight loss success stories

    Tracked from weight loss success stories 2014/07/31 14:41  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  68. Subject: weight loss calculator

    Tracked from weight loss calculator 2014/07/31 14:49  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  69. Subject: good Muscle building workouts

    Tracked from good Muscle building workouts 2014/07/31 18:49  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  70. Subject: www.brainbulb.net

    Tracked from www.brainbulb.net 2014/08/01 03:53  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  71. Subject: colon cleansing procedure

    Tracked from colon cleansing procedure 2014/08/01 18:28  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  72. Subject: herbal testosterone supplements

    Tracked from herbal testosterone supplements 2014/08/01 23:47  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  73. Subject:  Lifecell Anti-Wrinkle Cream

    Tracked from  Lifecell Anti-Wrinkle Cream 2014/08/02 14:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  74. Subject: Soyhiphop.In

    Tracked from Soyhiphop.In 2014/08/02 15:40  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  75. Subject: SkulpTek Pro

    Tracked from SkulpTek Pro 2014/08/03 00:32  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  76. Subject: raw green coffee beans

    Tracked from raw green coffee beans 2014/08/03 03:33  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  77. Subject: colon cleanse dr oz

    Tracked from colon cleanse dr oz 2014/08/03 17:00  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  78. Subject: where to buy garcinia cambogia

    Tracked from where to buy garcinia cambogia 2014/08/03 18:02  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  79. Subject: Majormusiclook.com

    Tracked from Majormusiclook.com 2014/08/03 18:33  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  80. Subject: la. Weight loss

    Tracked from la. Weight loss 2014/08/03 22:20  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  81. Subject: ethz.ch

    Tracked from ethz.ch 2014/08/04 07:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  82. Subject: wireshark.org

    Tracked from wireshark.org 2014/08/04 11:41  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  83. Subject: weight loss recipes

    Tracked from weight loss recipes 2014/08/04 20:08  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  84. Subject: blood sugar regulator

    Tracked from blood sugar regulator 2014/08/04 20:27  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  85. Subject: new.urbanchina.org

    Tracked from new.urbanchina.org 2014/08/04 20:32  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  86. Subject: anti-Aging institute

    Tracked from anti-Aging institute 2014/08/05 01:23  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  87. Subject: testosterone supplements uk

    Tracked from testosterone supplements uk 2014/08/05 06:50  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  88. Subject: trac.nbic.nl

    Tracked from trac.nbic.nl 2014/08/05 18:54  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  89. Subject: colon Cleanse benefits

    Tracked from colon Cleanse benefits 2014/08/05 23:44  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  90. Subject: benefiance Concentrated anti-wrinkle eye cream

    Tracked from benefiance Concentrated anti-wrinkle eye cream 2014/08/06 02:30  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  91. Subject: https://projects.taval.de/xregatta/ticket/44948

    Tracked from https://projects.taval.de/xregatta/ticket/44948 2014/08/06 03:26  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  92. Subject: diy plans pvc furniture plans pdf downloand

    Tracked from diy plans pvc furniture plans pdf downloand 2014/08/06 06:05  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  93. Subject: testosterone supplement review

    Tracked from testosterone supplement review 2014/08/06 06:52  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  94. Subject: ​weight loss plan

    Tracked from ​weight loss plan 2014/08/07 12:30  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  95. Subject: protein for muscle building

    Tracked from protein for muscle building 2014/08/08 17:12  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  96. Subject: myprise.com

    Tracked from myprise.com 2014/08/08 18:17  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  97. Subject: where to buy green coffee

    Tracked from where to buy green coffee 2014/08/10 20:16  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  98. Subject: Bed Plans

    Tracked from Bed Plans 2014/08/25 01:08  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  99. Subject: microwave pasta maker

    Tracked from microwave pasta maker 2014/09/01 23:09  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  100. Subject: blog writing

    Tracked from blog writing 2014/09/05 15:54  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  101. Subject: zucchini noodles

    Tracked from zucchini noodles 2014/09/08 03:17  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  102. Subject: Freeonlinetypinggames.com

    Tracked from Freeonlinetypinggames.com 2014/09/08 07:46  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  103. Subject: Family Financial Centers

    Tracked from Family Financial Centers 2014/09/16 09:29  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  104. Subject: melbourne pest control

    Tracked from melbourne pest control 2014/09/17 05:25  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  105. Subject: Doradztwo komputerowe zielona góra

    Tracked from Doradztwo komputerowe zielona góra 2014/09/18 19:59  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  106. Subject: gas grill reviews 2014

    Tracked from gas grill reviews 2014 2014/09/24 09:11  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  107. Subject: Adderall withdrawal

    Tracked from Adderall withdrawal 2014/09/27 19:46  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  108. Subject: Refuel Extreme

    Tracked from Refuel Extreme 2014/09/28 17:43  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  109. Subject: Fat-Burning Back Workout

    Tracked from Fat-Burning Back Workout 2014/09/28 21:53  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  110. Subject: nuvitaderm Review

    Tracked from nuvitaderm Review 2014/09/29 08:32  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  111. Subject: Testocore Advanced

    Tracked from Testocore Advanced 2014/09/30 22:53  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  112. Subject: Nuvo Cleanse

    Tracked from Nuvo Cleanse 2014/10/01 14:18  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  113. Subject: Simply Garcinia

    Tracked from Simply Garcinia 2014/10/02 03:26  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  114. Subject: best wordpress plugins 2014

    Tracked from best wordpress plugins 2014 2014/10/02 17:30  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  115. Subject: Nautre Fits Colon Cleanse

    Tracked from Nautre Fits Colon Cleanse 2014/10/03 09:23  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  116. Subject: dermefface fx7

    Tracked from dermefface fx7 2014/10/04 05:31  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  117. Subject: derma youth pro Reviews

    Tracked from derma youth pro Reviews 2014/10/04 11:03  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  118. Subject: lycanthrope

    Tracked from lycanthrope 2014/10/06 04:44  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  119. Subject: raspberry ketone renew Reviews

    Tracked from raspberry ketone renew Reviews 2014/10/08 23:34  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  120. Subject: swing doors uk

    Tracked from swing doors uk 2014/10/09 16:55  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  121. Subject: metal roof

    Tracked from metal roof 2014/10/12 05:44  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  122. Subject: Simply Green Coffee

    Tracked from Simply Green Coffee 2014/10/12 20:59  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  123. Subject: The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 1

    Tracked from The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 1 2014/10/13 08:35  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  124. Subject: Pure & Easy Slim

    Tracked from Pure & Easy Slim 2014/10/19 23:25  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  125. Subject: vimax in singapore

    Tracked from vimax in singapore 2014/10/29 00:51  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  126. Subject: kredyt bez zaswiadczen

    Tracked from kredyt bez zaswiadczen 2014/10/30 08:25  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  127. Subject: kredyt bez zaświadczeń

    Tracked from kredyt bez zaświadczeń 2014/10/31 02:13  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  128. Subject: pozyczka bez bik

    Tracked from pozyczka bez bik 2014/11/02 03:42  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  129. Subject: kredyt bez dochodu

    Tracked from kredyt bez dochodu 2014/11/03 03:49  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  130. Subject: Avoir Skin Care Review

    Tracked from Avoir Skin Care Review 2014/11/03 13:13  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  131. Subject: kredyt bez dochodu

    Tracked from kredyt bez dochodu 2014/11/06 22:11  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  132. Subject: myphamhanquocso1

    Tracked from myphamhanquocso1 2014/11/09 05:56  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  133. Subject: pozyczka bez zaswiadczen

    Tracked from pozyczka bez zaswiadczen 2014/11/10 04:34  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  134. Subject: cpa money

    Tracked from cpa money 2014/12/25 16:56  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  135. Subject: dr Anders Struksnes

    Tracked from dr Anders Struksnes 2015/02/18 05:53  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  136. Subject: How to get anyone's facebook password

    Tracked from How to get anyone's facebook password 2015/05/28 02:42  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET :: 그 즈음

  137. Subject: That is the right weblog for anyone who wants to seek out out about this topic. You realize so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I truly would want…HaHa). You positively put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Gre.

    Tracked from GYUHANG.NET :: 2016/05/31 19:24  삭제

    I found a great...

  138. Subject: best DNA tests

    Tracked from best DNA tests 2016/07/17 15:00  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::

  139. Subject: sellers agent

    Tracked from sellers agent 2016/12/13 03:22  삭제

    GYUHANG.NET ::